Long long ago, there was a cat kingdom. The peaceful society owed their genesis to a group of cats, fed up of being chased by dogs, hyenas and jackals of the jungles. So they chose a nice hilltop that provided them safety from wild carnivores. They could leave their young under the careful watch of a few muscled cats, to foray in the jungle for rodents, rabbits, shrews, moles, birds, insects, reptiles, amphibians, fish etc for feeding their young and themselves.
Over the years, the tribe swelled and made progress by leaps and bounds. A nice little fort was built around the hill and some civets, lynxes and pumas also begged to join the fraternity after seeing the safety of the cat kingdom. Some enterprising felines opened businesses for selling rat traps and milk that they stole from the nearby human habitation. An added attraction was a beauty parlor that some Siamese cats had opened. Soon there were cafeterias and bakeries.
Not very far behind came the catcalls and catfights. It started with a catty comment from Mrs Lynx in respect of Mrs Civet looking a little too foxy. Smiling like a Cheshire cat, Mrs Civet called Mrs Lynx a fat cat. Mrs Lynx jumped as a cat on the hot tin roof and raised hell. The fight went on till someone called the city council chairman, Mr Puma.
Mr Puma made a wrong start by mentioning that lynxes are known to be hot tempered, and that started a class war between various cat fraternities. For days on, there were fights between Lynxes and Civets, Lynxes and wildcats and so on. . Then after having been bruised badly, the cats decided to get a neutral umpire to settle the fight between the various races and sections of the cat society.
Initially they thought of calling another cat family. Panthers and tigers were mentioned, but then everyone backed out because the large cats will be more interested in solving their own hunger problems with so many cats available for easy meals. So they agreed to call a clutch of monkeys.
Three monkey leaders arrived. On the way the monkeys were astounded by the opulence and the progress of the cat kingdom. The three kept looking at each other with a single thought on their minds. How to take it all away, for their families and friends?
The eldest monkey started by introducing himself. He said that his grandfather had fought for the rights of the grass eating animals a century back. So he understands the issues of equality and animal rights. And that he is the best authority on the ‘Law of the jungle”, which he said is frequently used by even human beings in the lands of Bharat.
The lynxes, the wildcats, Pumas and other fraternities started complaining against each other loudly and together. The senior monkey pacified them and assured them that he will bring an equitable solution to the problem at hand. The senior monkey also mentioned that there will be a 10% fee because the problem is complex and the three monkeys will have to spend many days working out the solution. All cats, in the heat of their dislike for each other, agreed without a thought.
Thereafter, the senior monkey laid out his hypothesis,
- It is not Mrs Lynx v/s Mrs Civet, it is a class struggle.
- The recent fight is only a symptom of the underlying class inequalities and the frustration thereof.
- We will like to redistribute the wealth in a way that it benefits all equally.
- For this, all cats, without exception will have to submit all their wealth to us.
- We will take 10% as our facilitation and distribute the rest to all cats equally.
So, all cats brought out their finery, furs, food and family jewels. The cats having no idea of counting and percentages, looked at as monkeys divided the cats’ hard earned assets with a logic that was beyond the clever cats. It went on like this,
One for the lynxes, 10% for me; one for the bobcats, 10 % for me; one for the civets, 10% for me. And so it continued. The cats saw that they had equal parts now, but the monkeys had the biggest pile.
Puma, the city council chairman did make a feeble objection on the goings on, but the senior monkey told him, “You have elected to appoint us as purveyors of justice, now you are duty bound to keep quiet, whatever we do”
And so it happened. The so called class struggle had its first resolution with the clever cats losing a large part of their assets and monkeys richer by a multiple.
Moral: Social equity is best served by harmonious relations. Arbiters and bad arithmetic can ruin you.